Extraterrestrial civilization must exist, but why can’t it be found? Is the method wrong?

Mankind has searched for extraterrestrial civilization for many years without seeing a single hair. The Drake equation and Fermi’s paradox appeared in the last century, both of which are theories about finding aliens. More than half a century has passed. Have these theories worked? Let’s discuss it together and figure it out.

The level of scientific and technological civilization limits the ability of human beings to observe.

The basic common sense now is that life or civilization can only be born on planets. So far, humans have not found any life in the solar system, not even a single bacteria or cell, let alone civilization. However, it is not yet possible to deny the existence of low-level life within the solar system. Scientists believe that the most likely planets for life are Mars, Titan, and Europa. Even if life is actually discovered on these planets in the future, it is still very low-level, and civilization is impossible to exist.

Then the only way to look for extraterrestrial civilization is to turn outside the solar system. So far, more than 4,000 planets have been discovered outside the solar system. The nearest star, Proxima Centauri, has been found to be accompanied by planets, which is 4.2 light-years away. The farthest planet has been found to be 24722.65 light-years away. This is a planet of the red dwarf system close to the galactic center, named OGLE-2018-BLG-0677.

So far, no signs of life or civilization have been found on all planets. It is not certain that among the more than 4,000 planets discovered, there is no life or civilization. Because human observation methods are very limited, even the star Proxima Centauri can only see one bright spot at a distance of 4 light-years from us, and even the planets are invisible. The reason why we know that there is a planet is based on the phenomenon of obscuration of the planet’s viewing direction when it moves around the star, and based on its light cycle and gravitational perturbation “guess” and calculated it.

Almost all the more than 4,000 extrasolar planets were discovered in this way, and there are less than 10 planets that can see a light and shadow entity, so it is impossible to prove whether there is life on them. But it can almost be determined that there is no high-level civilization on it. Only when the level of civilization is able to change the state of stars can it be observed by humans.

Therefore, so far, humans have not made any changes to the solar system. If there is an extraterrestrial civilization on the same level as humans, and observing the earth a few light years away, it is impossible to determine whether there is a civilization here; in the same way, humans are also It is impossible to observe civilizations of the same level as humans outside the solar system.

The power of the radio waves also limits the observation distance.

But at least one thing is that humans can send radio waves to communicate with extraterrestrials. In 1974, mankind sent the first greeting telecommunications to extraterrestrial civilization through the “Arecibo” radio telescope. So far, this greeting radio wave has traveled for more than 40 years, which is more than 40 light years away. Haven’t received any response yet. If extraterrestrial civilizations have reached the level of humans thousands of years ago, their understanding of electromagnetic waves should be the same. The electromagnetic waves they emit should have reached the earth long ago, but humans have activated huge radio telescopes or ray telescopes to “listen” “For decades, it has not yet received a valuable signal.

Can this be said that at least in the range of thousands of light-years or even tens of thousands of light-years around us, there is no civilization? It’s still not sure. Because even the emission of electromagnetic waves requires huge power and is directional. There are various electromagnetic interferences in the universe, such as black holes and electromagnetic waves emitted by pulsars. The intensity of these electromagnetic waves is far stronger than the power emitted by humans. In contrast, the communication power emitted by humans is still very weak. The attenuation is very strong, how far can it go, or if there is an extraterrestrial civilization’s listening ability, can it receive these weak signals? Human listening is the same. If the electromagnetic wave signal sent by extraterrestrial civilization is very weak, can we hear it?

These are the uncertain reasons why mankind has not discovered extraterrestrial civilization. In addition, there are many reasons why extraterrestrial civilizations in the universe are difficult to encounter. Now let’s understand some famous theories about extraterrestrial civilizations of the century.

Drake equation

Regarding the existence of extraterrestrial civilization, there have been conjectures or theoretical arguments in the scientific community for a long time. The more famous one is the Drake equation proposed by American astronomer Frank Drake in the 1960s. This is a formula that speculates that humans may come into contact with the extraterrestrial civilization of the Milky Way. There are two expressions, namely (quote):

Formula 1 is: N=Ng×Fp×Ne×Fl×Fi×Fc×FL

Formula 2 is: N=R*×Fp×Ne×Fl×Fi×Fc×L

Formula 1 means:

The number of civilizations in the galaxy that may communicate with us (N) = the number of stars in the galaxy (Ng) × the proportion of stars with planets (Fp) × the number of terrestrial planets in each planetary system (Ne) × the proportion of habitable planets with life evolution (Fl) × the probability of evolving intelligent creatures (Fi) × the probability of intelligent life being able to communicate (Fc) × the proportion of the duration of scientific and technological civilization in the planetary life cycle (FL).

The difference between Formula 2 and Formula 1 is that R* replaces Ng, and L replaces FL. R* is the average rate of the formation of stars in the Milky Way, and L is the lifespan of scientific and technological civilization.

Formula reasoning:

If the Milky Way stars are in a stable state (consistent with modern observations), then R* is equal to the number of stars in the Milky Way (Ng) divided by the average star lifetime (Ls).

R*×L is equal to (Ng/Ls) L=Ng(L/Ls). Since (L/Ls) is basically the same as FL, the two expressions are equivalent.

Although the Drake equation is simple, it cannot be solved. The most uncertain term in this equation is the “existence time of scientific and technological civilization (L)” because this term depends on the scientific and technological civilization itself, some of which are known terms. Since L is the largest uncertain term, in the “Cyclops Project”, the equation can be simplified to N=L.

From the explanation of the formula cited above, we can see that many of these indicators are uncertain, so it is difficult to calculate the accurate number of civilizations in the galaxy. Some scientists believe that the basic values ​​that can be determined are: the number of stars in the Milky Way (Ng) is about 200 to 400 billion; the proportion of stars with planets (Fp) is conservatively estimated to be 10%; the number of terrestrial planets in each planetary system (Ne) The conservative value is 10%.

But in the formula, Fl, Fi, and Fc are difficult to determine. Cornell University astronomer Carl Sagan who participated in the equation research once gave an optimistic estimate, namely Fl*Fi*Fc=1/300, which is N≈10^7*FL, so the size of N depends on the size of FL.

But the biggest uncertainty in the equation is this FL, that is, the proportion of the duration of scientific and technological civilization in the life cycle of a planet. If we use the analogy of human civilization, the earth’s life cycle is about 10 billion years, how long can human science and technology civilization last? 10,000 years or 100 million years? Human science and technology civilization is less than 1,000 years old, and it is unpredictable how long it will last in the future. If it can last 100 million years, FL is 1%.

In this way, the number of galactic civilizations derived from the entire formula will be at least 100,000 or more. But if the scientific and technological civilization can only exist for 10,000 years on average, the FL will only be 0.000001, so that there may only be 10 civilizations in the galaxy; if the scientific and technological civilization can only exist for 1,000 years on average, the FL will be 0.0000001, and the galactic civilization may only be 1. This means that there is only human civilization.

Therefore, the chance that civilizations can perceive each other is too small.

In fact, the existence of human science and technology civilization should exceed 1,000 years, so other civilizations may exist in the galaxy. Even if there is really only one civilization in a galaxy like the Milky Way, astronomical observations now believe that there are at least 1 trillion galaxies in the observable universe, so there will be as many as trillions of civilizations. This is the optimistic side.

But what is frustrating is that the probability of these civilizations being able to perceive each other is very small, and the chance of meeting each other is even smaller.

For example, a galaxy as large as the Milky Way has only one civilization. In small galaxies such as the Large and Small Magellanic Clouds near us, it is difficult to nurture or develop civilizations that can communicate with each other. The nearest large galaxy is the Andromeda Galaxy. It is 2.54 million light-years away from us. Not to mention the attenuation of communication signals, it will take 2.54 million years to reach each other even if they are transmitted to each other.

If the technological life of civilization is only 10,000 years, can this signal be received? Therefore, the key is how long a technological civilization that can communicate can last, and that is the key to whether or not civilizations can communicate.

Fermi Paradox

There was also a famous theory about extraterrestrial civilization in the last century, called the Fermi Paradox. This theory was put forward by the famous physicist and Nobel Prize winner Enrique Fermi in 1950. The simplest and most famous sentence of this paradox is “Since aliens exist, where are they?”

Specifically, the popular explanation of Fermi’s paradox has several views: 1. The universe has been formed for 13.8 billion years, and the earth should not be the only civilization. There are many planets in the universe that are much older than the earth, and the civilization there should be very Ancient, so even a very slow space flight, it only takes a few million years to reach us, why did we not find them? 2. Even if civilization is scarce and interstellar travel is difficult to encounter, then any civilization must expand and emigrate to an advanced stage. There must be activities of nearby stars or galaxies, and at least communications should be sent out. Why didn’t we find it?

This theory has been widely valued in the astronomy community. Scientists have been exploring this problem for decades. In 1975, the famous American scholar Mike Hart published the “Explanation on the Absence of Extraterrestrial Civilization on Earth”, which was the first time that Fermi Paradox is discussed as a serious concept, and four explanations (quotations) are given to the Fermi paradox:

1. For extraterrestrial civilizations, interstellar travel is not yet feasible. 2. From the analysis of motivation, the extraterrestrial civilization does not intend to make contact with humans. 3. Extraterrestrial civilization has just emerged, and it will take some time to get in touch with humans. 4. The earth has been visited by alien civilizations, but we don’t know it. After discussing them one by one, Hart believed that the above four reasons were not valid, and the reverse conclusion drawn from this can only be that extraterrestrial civilization does not exist at all.

Physicist Stephen Weber published “Where is Extraterrestrial Civilization?” in 2002. In the book, 50 solutions to Fermi’s paradox are listed, which can be roughly summarized into three aspects: 1. There is no other civilization in the universe except for the earth’s human civilization; perhaps an alien civilization has always existed, or once existed, But they can’t contact us; 3. Alien civilizations have been to the earth, they don’t want us to know, and we can’t know.

These answers seem to cover why we have not discovered extraterrestrial civilization so far.

There is also a view that gamma-ray bursts kill civilization in the cradle.

Some extreme celestial events in the universe, such as supernova explosions, neutron star collisions, black hole collisions, etc., will periodically or irregularly produce gamma-ray bursts with huge energy. These huge energies have killed more than 90% of life or civilization in the universe. Moreover, it is never possible for civilizations to rise to the advanced stage, so there is no opportunity for mutual perception between civilizations, let alone the opportunity to meet.

There is also a view that the diversity of the cosmic environment has created the diversity of civilizations. The organs and methods of perception and communication of various civilizations are likely to be completely different, which makes it more difficult to perceive each other. The so-called meeting, why knowing each other may also apply to other places. What about civilization.

Of course, all these are just conjectures. Human beings are still using all the most advanced scientific and technological means to tirelessly search for extraterrestrial civilizations, hoping to find our soulmates, so that humans will no longer be alone in this vast universe. Will human efforts be rewarded? In other words, will the higher civilizations outside the earth find humans? I don’t know, everything is possible. Maybe there will be new discoveries tomorrow, but we don’t know, we look forward to it.

Leave a Reply